79775 Overseas Highway, Upper Matecumbe Key Islamorada, FL 33036

About this home

A once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own one of South Florida's most iconic properties. Welcome to Tea Table Key, a breathtaking 15-acre private island estate, accessible by car or by boat, located just minutes from downtown Islamorada and directly across from the famous Alligator Reef Lighthouse. Surrounded by vivid turquoise waters, this extraordinary sanctuary offers complete privacy and a front-row seat to nature's daily spectacle -- herons and egrets gliding overhead, pelicans diving at sunrise, and eagles soaring above your shoreline. Enjoy the rare luxury of total seclusion without sacrificing convenience. Within minutes, you're immersed in Islamorada's finest restaurants, art galleries, and shopping, yet at home you're embraced by the stillness of your own island world. Conveniently located approximately 1 hour and 30 minutes from Miami International Airport, or a 25-minute helicopter or seaplane ride, Tea Table Key offers an unmatched combination of accessibility and exclusivity. The island features a beautifully updated 6-bedroom residence, along with a tennis court and private dockage. Whether you choose to enjoy the comfort of the existing home or envision an entirely new luxury residence, Tea Table Key presents a truly incomparable canvas in one of the most sought-after destinations in the Florida Keys.

Property details

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Year Built

1971

Lot Size

689,990 sq ft

Annual Taxes

$84,132/yr

Subdivision

Tea Table (79.5)

Days on Market

241

Listed

January 16, 2026

MLS #

618152

Location