1618 Flagler Avenue, Key West, FL 33040

About this home

First time ever on the market! This is an excellent opportunity to own a charming single-family home in Key West. Lovingly maintained and custom-built for the current owners, this property has remained in the same family for over 60 years. This tranquil residence features 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms and sits on a spacious 5,016 sq. ft. lot. The home includes off-street, covered parking for one vehicle. Recent updates include central A/C and a new water heater. A detached metal storage shed provides additional storage space. The backyard offers a relaxing outdoor area--perfect for enjoying the island lifestyle. Inside, tile flooring runs throughout the home for easy maintenance. The yard features mature tropical landscaping with local fruit bearing trees. Centrally located, this property is just minutes from shopping, schools, dining, and beaches. This mid-century modern home offers great potential for upgrades, renovations, or possible additions to suit your needs. The property is being sold as-is and is currently tenant-occupied, offering flexibility for investors or future homeowners ready to create their own vision. Listing agents are related to the sellers.

Property details

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Year Built

1958

Lot Size

5,016 sq ft

Annual Taxes

$6,285/yr

Subdivision

Nuevo Progresso (2.0)

Days on Market

164

Listed

April 18, 2026

MLS #

619553

Location