817 Terry Lane, Key West, FL 33040

About this home

One Bedroom / One bathroom PLUS super cool Sleeping Loft! THIS is it! Step into a piece of Old Town Key West history. Built in 1928, this storybook Old Town cottage captures everything to love about Key West including its timeless character and that easy island rhythm you can feel the moment you arrive. Light, bright, and beautifully furnished, it's move-in ready, the perfect turn-key retreat for anyone dreaming of a second home or an easy vacation rental in the heart of Key West. Inside, you'll find soaring wood-vaulted ceilings and warm floors features that hint to island's past. The updated Kitchen is ready for entertaining, while the additional and spaciously airy sleeping loft adds extra space and great character, while the private back deck invites unforgettable evenings dining under the stars. Out front, the iconic porch is made for slow evenings, and people-watching ... the classic Key West pastime. Just two blocks from Duval Street, this location is unbeatable, it's close enough to walk to the best restaurants, galleries, and shops, yet tucked away for peace and privacy. Even better, it's in the coveted X-Zone, so no flood insurance is required, and yes, it has its own, coveted off-street parking spot Phenomenal Vacation Rental and 1031 Exchange potential. This isn't just a home; it's a private oasis. It's YOUR Key West story waiting to be written.

Property details

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Year Built

1928

Lot Size

840 sq ft

Annual Taxes

$5,953/yr

Subdivision

Old Town - Unrecord (1.0)

Days on Market

243

Listed

January 15, 2026

MLS #

618122

Location